(805) 686-1234 [email protected]

By Dennis Rizzo & John Elliott

On Rizzo’s Radar — Bentley Price Associates

Four months ago, in the very first conversation that kicked off this series, John Elliott said something we let pass in a single sentence: “The objective is not more bureaucracy. The objective is greater clarity.” At the time, it read almost like an aside. It wasn’t. It turned out to be the answer to the question CEOs ask him more than any other, usually right after a quarter where something important slipped: how do you build real accountability without burying the organization in process?

We’ve spent the months since then building toward that answer. We started with false alignment, the signals that tell you a leadership team is nodding along without actually agreeing. We moved to time-to-value, and why a new executive’s first 90 days hinge on whether the organization already shares a leadership language built on Jim Kouzes and Barry Posner’s Five Practices of Exemplary Leadership®, the model at the heart of their book The Leadership Challenge®. This month, we go back to where this all started, and ask John to make good on that one sentence.

“When execution slips, most leaders reach for structure,” John told me. “Another status meeting. Another approval layer. A longer weekly report. It feels like accountability. Usually it’s the opposite. You’ve made activity easier to see and ownership harder to find.”

The numbers back him up. In their widely cited Fortune article “Why CEOs Fail,” Ram Charan and Geoffrey Colvin found that roughly 70% of CEO failures come not from poor strategy but from poor execution. Jim Collins and Jerry Porras, authors of Built to Last, put it more bluntly: building a visionary company requires 1% vision and 99% alignment. Strategy, in other words, is execution, and execution runs on accountability.

Accountability Is a Clarity Problem, Not an Attitude Problem

John’s first move was to reframe the problem. When a commitment gets missed, leaders tend to diagnose attitude: a lack of ownership, urgency, or drive. In his experience, that diagnosis is usually wrong.

“Accountability isn’t about attitude. It’s about clarity,” he said. “Most breakdowns come from assumptions, and most of those assumptions start with the leader.”

He calls them the Five Illusions of Accountability. Each one sounds reasonable in the moment, and each one creates false confidence:

Illusion

What you hear afterward

What actually happened

Clarity

“I thought you meant…”

The expectation was never stated precisely enough to be misunderstood out loud

Agreement

“I assumed we were aligned.”

Silence in the room was taken for consent

Priority

“I didn’t know this was urgent.”

Everything was important, so nothing was

Competence

“I thought they could handle it.”

Capability was assumed rather than checked and supported

Follow-Through

“I figured they were on it.”

No one looked until the deadline had already passed

If the Agreement illusion sounds familiar, it should. It is the same pattern behind the first warning sign in our false-alignment piece, silence in the room, now showing up three months later as a missed deliverable or outcome.

Notice what the bureaucratic response does to each illusion. More meetings don’t create clarity if no one checks for understanding. Longer reports don’t create follow-through if no one reads them until something breaks. Structure layered on top of an illusion just makes the illusion more expensive.

The Leader’s Role on the Ladder

To make this visible, John uses the framework of the Accountability Ladder, a coaching model long used in leadership development. From the bottom up, the rungs are:

  1. Victim
  2. Blame
  3. Wait and Hope
  4. Acknowledge Reality
  5. Own It
  6. Find Solutions
  7. Make It Happen

The line between rungs three and four is the line between being a spectator and being an owner. What surprises most CEOs is how often their own behavior keeps people below it.

“Leaders unintentionally hold people on the lower rungs,” John said. “They rescue. They solve the problem for them. They give vague expectations and never check whether they were understood. Then they wonder why nobody owns anything.”

His answer is what he calls the No-Rescue Rule: don’t solve, coach. When a direct report brings a problem, the leader’s job is to ask what they see, what they’d recommend, and what they need, not to take the problem back. John uses Kouzes and Posner’s practice of Enable Others to Act to show what this looks like in real time; the No-Rescue Rule is that practice in its most practical form. Every rescue teaches the team that the real owner of the problem is the boss.

The Bigger Picture

The difference between accountability and bureaucracy, as John describes it, comes down to direction. Bureaucracy pushes control down from the top: more checkpoints, more sign-offs, more reporting up the chain. Accountability pulls ownership up from the people doing the work, because they can see the strategy, they know what success looks like, and they have a leader who coaches instead of rescues.

John closed our conversation the way he closes his workshops:

Clarity creates confidence. Confidence creates ownership. Ownership creates results.

Before the next status meeting gets scheduled, it’s worth asking a simpler question first: is this a structure problem, or is it a clarity problem? Most of the time, it’s the second one. It’s the question John spends most of his time helping leadership teams answer and validate with data using Line-of-Sight℠.

None of this holds together without something that lives above any single conversation between a leader and a direct report: whether people across the organization can actually see a line from the strategy down to the work in front of them today. John calls that Line of Sight, and diagnosing it runs on five specific capabilities, capabilities substantial enough to deserve their own conversation. That’s where we go next.

Bentley Price Associates
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.